Texas Teen Accused of Stabbing Classmate Sparks Outrage Over Lavish Living

Karmelo Anthony, 17, is facing murder charges for the fatal stabbing of fellow student Austin Metcalf during a track meet in Frisco, Texas, on April 2. Released from jail after his bond was reduced from $1 million to $250,000, Anthony is now living in a luxury gated neighborhood, which has drawn backlash from the community.

Anthony’s lawyers argued the original bond was too high, claiming financial hardship. However, his current residence—a rental in the upscale Richwoods area, where rent is about $3,500 a month—has neighbors questioning that narrative. “These folks are clearly not struggling financially,” one resident said. Another added, “This doesn’t sit right. I don’t think he should be back here.”

The family has raised over $440,000 through a GiveSendGo campaign, which claims Anthony acted in self-defense and criticizes the media for spreading “false and damaging” narratives. Despite this, prosecutors questioned why the money wasn’t used for bond. The family said funds had already been spent on legal fees and security measures.

Defense attorney Mike Howard explained, “They’re under immense pressure. There are younger children in the house, and safety is a concern.”

Anthony is under house arrest with an ankle monitor and 24/7 adult supervision as he awaits trial. His home is located less than a mile from Centennial High School, where both he and Metcalf were students.

The incident reportedly began over a dispute about seating. Anthony told police he acted in self-defense, but the case remains under investigation.

The situation has sparked public debate over wealth, justice, and the ethics of fundraising for criminal defense. As one neighbor put it, “Honestly, it would probably be better for everyone” if the family moved.